Sunday, December 30, 2012

"Daughters are neither Safe Inside the Womb nor Outside"

A poster that was widely circulated on Face book saying "A nation where daughters are neither safe inside the womb nor outside" very aptly highlights how badly women are treated in "Shining", "Incredible", and "Developing" India.   

 

Right to Equality: The Constitution of India prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth. But even after more than 60 years, the Gender Equality & Empowerment of Women continues to remain in Millennium Goals of Govt. of India. The disparity is evident from the fact that percentage of Women in Parliament is hardly 10%, while the employed women in non-agriculture sector (2005) is around 18%.

If the political leaders shedding the crocodile tears and making right noises over the reprehensible crime in New Delhi on 16 th December, are serious and sincere about empowerment of women, they should immediately pass the 'Women's Reservation Bill" so that at least 180 Female MPs can be present in the next Lok Sabha.

The 23 year old brave daughter of India, as one research scholar has rightly put it, did not die of multiorgan failure, but it was the multiorgan failure of this Society and the State which killed her.

What is the accountability of Senior Politicians and Officials presiding over malfunctioning of the State Administration? It is not as if  there are  no laws dealing with rape and sexual assault, but it is the monumental apathy and failure of the insensitive and unresponsive  Police, Judiciary and Neta/Babu Nexus, made them ineffective and non functional.

As a society and individual, we are equally responsible and accountable, because of our apathy, lack of compassion and not raising our voices against incidents of this nature happening around us. Every one of us can make a difference by our attitudinal and behavioral change, to raise our voice and make it heard in the right quarters against atrocities of this nature.                             

Thursday, December 13, 2012

Bulk Drug Industry Corporate Commitment to Community

Blanket of Corruption between Politics, Administration & Bulk Drug Industry seems to have been too tightly woven!

The AP Pollution Control Board (APPCB) Task Force meeting scheduled to be held today, Thursday, 13 th December is understood to have been postponed, because of the absence of Member Secretary on health grounds. It is reliably learnt that Member Secretary chosen to keep away from the meeting to avoid decision making under duress from the powers that matter.

As a result, the defaulting 12 major Bulk Drug Units, indulging in the production of un-consented products and/or producing more than the permitted capacities, under the disguise of Zero Liquid Discharges ( ZLD) got out of the net for the time being.

In the meantime, there is every possibility of the state government acting on the recommendation of APPCB, in its meeting held on 4 th December and accept the recommendation of High Level Expert Committee namely- permitting expansion of existing industries having ZLD facility, on case to case to basis in relaxation of Ban Order, based on legal advice.

 

What more does the Bulk Drug Industry want? The Bulk Drug Industry is willing to take risk to the bitter end, in their greed for profit paved with the lives of the people. The state is not prepared to take action against these irreprehensible environmental crimes, which often damage the community more seriously than the criminal offences of the conventional kind.

_________________________________________________________________________

 

National Investment Board

 The high power Cabinet Committee on Investments (National Investment Board), under the chairmanship of Prime Minister to accord expeditious approval to projects of over Rs 1,000 Crore, is only meant for the benefit of large firms and investors and  to bypass the required green clearances for mega projects, while having no provision for redressing the concerns of the people affected by these projects.
____________________________________________________________________-

Sunday, December 9, 2012

Dishonesty of Pharmaceutical Industry?

 "If the whole pharmacopeia were to be sunk to the bottom of seas, that will be that much good for people and that much worse for the fishes"

                                                                                                                                                                 - Oliver Wendell Holmes

 "There is no pill for every ill but there is definitely an ill following every pill"

                                                                                                                                 - Professor H.M.Hegde

 

"The pharmaceutical industry is the most lucrative, the most cynical and the least ethical of all the industries.  It is like an Octopus with tentacles that has infiltrated all the decision-making bodies, world health organizations, governments, parliaments, high administrations in health and hospitals and the medical profession."

                                                                                                 - Professor Philippe Evans, Director of Necker Institute, France

 

"In all, 26 companies, including eight of the 10 top players in the global industry, have been found to be acting dishonestly"

                                                                                                                                                             -  The New England Journal of Medicine  

 

Acknowledgement: Extracts from the Article "Money is Mammon in pharmaceutical   world "by Prof.H.M.Hegde published

                                      in THE HINDU, December 09, 2012

 

___________________________________________________________________

 

Friday, November 23, 2012

Lifting of Ban on Bulk Drug Units

 
The AP Government is understood to be considering, to lift the ban imposed on Bulk Drug Units by G.O.62 dated 28-04-1999, in compliance with the Supreme Court Directive in interim orders dated.12.05.1998 in W.P.N0.1056/90.

 

The justification being put forward for lifting the ban appears to be that the ban order of a decade old, was based on the then prevailing obsolete technologies / processes being adopted / used by the Bulk Drug Industry. The industry can achieve zero discharges by adopting the State of Art Technologies / Processes now available.

 

Ground Realities

 

The Supreme Court in W.P.N0.1056 of 1990, as far back as 1998, directed the industries for segregation of waste streams containing non-degradable pollutants from the degradable ones, for treatment / disposal at the very source of their generation ie at the industry itself, instead of sending it to CETPs. But unfortunately, neither the industry implemented nor the regulating agencies enforced its implementation and the untreated / under-treated effluents, continue to be discharged into 18 KM Pipeline / Sewers / Drains /STPs / Musi River unchecked.

 

The enforcement of measures for the discharges from CETPs to comply with the Surface Water Standards, as stipulated in the Joint Action Plan of CPCB & APPCB of 2-7-2007 submitted to Supreme Court in W.P.No 476 / 2005, & W.P.No 441 / 2005, does not seem to be effective. If they conform to surface water standards, what is the need to transfer the so called treated effluents of PETL, at considerable cost and effort into Sewers by 18 KM Pipeline, ultimately finding their way, through STPs, into Musi River?

 

It is abundantly clear that pollution levels are on the increase, as Pattancheru- Bollaram was identified by CPCB in 2010, as one of the critically polluted industrial clusters in the country. It can also be judged by the fact that as late as  2012, the APPCB served closure notice  to 12 Bulk Drug Companies, whose manufacturing units located  around Hyderabad were indulging in manufacture of 'Unconsented' Products' and stepping up of quantity of production without mandatory prior Environmental Clearance and leading to increased pollution load. 

 

Inaction

 

In accordance with sub-section 15 (1) of The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 , whoever fails to comply with or contravenes any of the provisions of this Act, or the Rules made or Orders or Directions issued there under shall, in respect of each such failure or contravention , be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to five years or with fine which may extend for one Lakh Rupees, or with both?

 

But, there does not seem to be a single instance, in which penal action was initiated against repeatedly defaulting units with impunity during the last two decades or so. Unless non-compliance of rules / regulations is made a High-Risk Business by strict implementation of the provisions of the Act by stringent Penal Action, the situation may not be very different even after switching over to so called State of Art Technology /  Process.

 

Conclusion

 

Why should the Bulk Drug Industry spend money on State of Art Technology / Process to minimize / avoid  pollution load, when it can be passed on To Others, To Elsewhere and To Future, with out of much of a Risk ?  

 

The Answer is  a) Non -Compliance is to be made A High Risk Business instead of being A High Profit Business as at present .

                             b) Proof of Burden should be on the Polluter  and

                             c) Polluter Pays Principal should be made applicable

 

Wednesday, November 14, 2012

Kolleru Area Downsizing - Not only Pelicans, Even Eluru & Vijayawada may be at Risk

 The recent floods caused by "Cyclone Nilam" in the various drains– Budameru, Tammileru etc.- that empty into Kolleru Lake, have caused the water to rise up and cross the +8 feet contour. This has resulted in flooding of several colonies along the banks of Budameru in Vijayawada City, for several days.

 

Dr.Azeez Committee Report

 

 Dr. Aziz Committee clearly stated that every few years, the lake spreads over +7 feet contour and on an average once in eight years the lake fills to above +9 feet contour, holding up to 1222 million cubic meters of water in contrast to the storage of about mere 150 and 300 million cubic meters at +3 and +5 contours respectively.

 

 It is also stated that if Kolleru Lake is resized by reducing its effective functional area, inflow during rains would spread far wider and away into upstream areas, submerging bed and belt villages and at times the towns of Eluru, Gudivada and Vijayawada. The elevated water will remain for a longer period, as it is to be drained by only one outlet, the Upputeru, that is now ill equipped to carry all the waters.

 

Appeal

 

 In the light of the position explained above and the urgency & importance of the matter, MOEF, GOI and AP State Govt are  requested for early implementation of the recommendations of Dr. Azeez Committee, which were accepted in Toto by the Standing Committee of NBWL, without any further delay.

____________________________________________________________

Friday, November 9, 2012

Can Avoid Power Cuts by Cutting Down Losses!

 Historical data of AP Power System

As per the "White Paper" dated 31.3.1999, prepared by A.P. TRANSCO, the total of 36380 MU units were available for sale in the system during 1997-98. The Energy Audit of AP Power System conducted month-wise, showed only 34799.50 MU as the total energy input from April 1997 to March 1998. Presumably the unaccounted difference of 1580.50 MU, which works out to be 4.34% of total units available for sale, is accounted as Transmission Losses ( 33KV & above) of the system.

The findings of the Energy Audit also showed 23254.82 MU, as the total actual sales during the year under the following categories.

     *HT Consumers    7703.79 MU (22.14%)       Metered

     *LT Consumers     7260.91 MU (20.86%)       Metered

     *Agl.  Consumers   8290.12 MU (23.82%)       Unmetered and estimated

The balance of 11544.68 MU, which works out to be 33.17% of energy input, was shown as energy lost in the system, over and above 4.34% transmission losses accounted for earlier. These losses in Distribution Network, may be classified into technical losses & commercial losses because of theft. The technical losses were estimated to be of the order of 6960 MU, working out to be 20% and the balance 4584.68 MU i.e. 13.17% is being treated as commercial losses. The total energy lost in the T&D system-13125.18 MU- is equivalent to the installed capacity of 1875 MW, assuming 7MU per MW at 80% Plant Utilization.

No Change even after more than a Decade

 As per the data available in APERC Tariff Order of July 2010, a total of 77, 828.26 MU is approved for purchase by 4 DISCOMS, permitting Transmission Losses of 4.86 % and Distribution Losses of 13.84%, accounting for total loss of 12,790.76 MU,equivalent to installed capacity of  about 1825 MW .

As the LT Sales constitute substantial part of the total sales of the DISCOMS, the verifiable data regarding LT Consumption is of very serious concern. The total metered and billed LT sales, is hovering around 40% of the total LT input since mid 90 s and according to APERC the total LT metered sales of CPDCL, even during 2009-10, are less than 50% of the total LT input.

 The unmetered LT consumption is being appropriated under agricultural consumption and the losses by a process of estimation, with the possible intention of keeping the losses low, at the risk of jacking up agricultural consumption.

Way Out

Even after a decade, there does not seem to be much of improvement in the performance of some of the DISCOMS in implementing SSM measures to bring down the losses, wastages, pilferage etc. in the power system. Some of the issues, which need to be given special attention to achieve definite time bound targets, are;

*Reduction of Transmission Losses, which are around more than 4%  since 1990 s   need to be brought down below 3% at the earliest.

*The 100% Metered LT Sales in sectors other than Agricultural Services, is to be  targeted with out any further delay, to practically eliminate commercial losses (10-15%) and for working out the exact technical losses with a view to  improve the LT network  and above all to create accountability on  the part of the field staff of the utilities, 

* Reduction of Distribution Losses, which hover around 15% need to be brought down  to below 10% in a given time frame.

* Agricultural Consumption figures continue to be controversial and arbitrary for over the  last 10 years which are being projected between 25% to 40%, with out any verifiable  data which can stand any scrutiny.

* Agriculture Consumption, even if it is to be given free, should be metered and accounted for, so as to bring in clarity regarding the amount to be subsidized by Govt. and accountability for Losses on the part of DICOMS   

______________________________________________________________________